Selecting the right mountain biking shoes is crucial for a comfortable and efficient ride. In this head-to-head review, we’ll pit two exceptional options against each other—the Five Ten Kestrel Pro Boa and the Shimano SH-ME702. These shoes cater to riders with different preferences and needs, ranging from fit and closure systems to intended use. Let’s explore how these two stack up.
I have wide feet. According to my initial research the Kestrel’s seemed to please online reviewers for accommodating a wide foot. I bought them and found I had a hot spot on right foot. Solution was to heat with a heat gun and stretch it out with a wedged in spark plug cleaner. This solved the problem.
Then it seemed like I was always having trouble clipping in during intense moments before big drops or knarly lines. My buddy was riding the SH-ME702’s. I tried them and found that they just clipped in easier for me. They also have a wide option which worked for me without having to get out my heat gun.
Five Ten Kestrel Pro Boa:
Fit and Closure System: The Kestrel Pro Boa boasts a cutting-edge Boa dial closure system, offering riders precision and convenience in adjusting their fit. This system ensures a secure and personalized fit, contributing to comfort and performance. Additionally, Velcro straps provide further adjustability for fine-tuning.
Sole: Equipped with a composite sole, these shoes strike an admirable balance between stiffness for optimal power transfer and flexibility for walkability. What sets them apart is the inclusion of Five Ten’s renowned Stealth C4 rubber outsole, delivering unparalleled grip for those technical off-bike moments, like hike-a-bike sections.
Durability: Durability is a hallmark of Five Ten’s offerings, and the Kestrel Pro Boa is no exception. Reinforced areas withstand the rigors of mountain biking, ensuring a long lifespan.
Intended Use: Designed primarily for cross-country and trail riding, these shoes are a perfect blend of performance and comfort. Whether you’re embarking on long rides or tackling varied terrain, the Kestrel Pro Boa provides the efficiency you need without sacrificing off-bike traction.
Weight: In the realm of weight-conscious gear, the Kestrel Pro Boa is among the lighter options, enhancing pedaling efficiency for riders who demand speed and agility.
Shimano SH-ME702:
Fit and Closure System: The SH-ME702 shoes opts for a speed lacing system that securely fits a wide range of foot shapes. Low-profile, reverse mount buckle securely holds foot. This system is as quick to adjust on the fly as a Boa system. Just put your finger under the flap and click click.
Sole: Featuring a strong reinforced “TORBAL” torsional midsole allows natural rider flow on descents. MICHELIN new compound rubber outsole offers superior traction, durability, stability, and slip resistance.
Durability: Shimano is renowned for the durability of its products, and the SH-ME702 shoes are no exception. Built with high-quality materials and reinforced areas, they’re built to withstand the demands of mountain biking.
Intended Use: Versatility is a defining characteristic of the SH-ME702 shoes. They’re suitable for a wide range of mountain biking disciplines, including cross-country, trail, and enduro. Riders looking for an all-around shoe that balances performance and comfort will find them appealing.
Weight: While not the absolute lightest, the SH-ME702 shoes strike an admirable balance between stiffness and weight. They cater to riders who value efficient pedaling while maintaining some walkability.
Comparison:
- Closure System: The Kestrel Pro Boa offers precise and customizable fit adjustments with its Boa system, while the SH-ME702 uses laces, providing a secure fit with slightly less on-the-fly adjustability with their closure system. But it works and seems to be very reliable.
- Fit: The Kestrel Pro Boa fits a wide foot, no doubt, however for me it was a little cramped in toe box, while the SH-ME702 offers a more relaxed fit in the Wide version, suitable for a broader range of foot shapes.
- Sole: Both shoes strike a commendable balance between stiffness for efficient pedaling and walkability. The Kestrel Pro Boa stands out with its Stealth C4 rubber outsole for exceptional off-bike grip. Still the MICHELIN rubber compound on the Shimano is superior.
- Durability: Both shoes are known for their durability, built to withstand the rigors of mountain biking. They are both super tough shoes withstanding sharp rocks.
- Intended Use: The Kestrel Pro Boa is tailored for cross-country and trail riding, whereas the SH-ME702 is a versatile option suitable for various mountain biking disciplines and it walks easier than the Kestrel, so it is more Enduro friendly.
- Weight: The Kestrel Pro Boa is generally lighter, making it a preferred choice for riders focused on weight savings.
Conclusion:
Choosing between the Five Ten Kestrel Pro Boa and the Shimano SH-ME702 ultimately hinges on your foot shape, riding style, and priorities. If you love the Boa closer system, the Kestrel Pro Boa is an exceptional choice. On the other hand, if you seek versatility, a comfortable fit for a wider range of foot shapes, and an all-around mountain biking shoe suitable for various disciplines, the SH-ME702 provides a reliable option with a lever click closure system. I found the Shimano’s easier to click in with my EggBeater pedals. Although after some playing around and moving the cleat almost entirely all the way to the back, I found the Kestrel improved significantly.